Despite Paige and her sisters' optimism about the Avatars vision of a Utopian future, Kyle doesn't share their positive outlook. He then forms an unlikely alliance with Zankou, but stipulates that the Charmed Ones don't get hurt in stopping the Avatars. As a result, Piper, Phoebe, and Paige fall under a spell that makes them extremely paranoid that causes them to attack an Avatar.

As Paige begins interviewing possible teaching candidates to hire as Magic School's newest literature professor, one of the applicants is a reformed demon looking to start a new life doing good. However, it doesn't take long for a sorcerer to cast a spell and turn him into Robin Hood and Phoebe as one of his maidens and cause the mortal world to see the happenings of magical life. Meanwhile, Leo receives his punishment from the Elders for his betrayal, and Inspector Sheridan is back on the job and with no memory of what transpired between the sisters and Agent Brody.