As Paige begins interviewing possible teaching candidates to hire as Magic School's newest literature professor, one of the applicants is a reformed demon looking to start a new life doing good. However, it doesn't take long for a sorcerer to cast a spell and turn him into Robin Hood and Phoebe as one of his maidens and cause the mortal world to see the happenings of magical life. Meanwhile, Leo receives his punishment from the Elders for his betrayal, and Inspector Sheridan is back on the job and with no memory of what transpired between the sisters and Agent Brody.

Leo's punishment is handed down by the Elders – he is wiped of his memories and stripped of his powers, stranded out in a sparsely populated area and has to find his way back home in order to find out where he truly belongs. Meanwhile, as she is faced with a future without Leo in it, Piper is attacked by a powerful demon and ends up in a coma where she is fighting for her life. It is while hovering between life and death that Piper is shocked to discover Cole waiting to see her. Phoebe has to say goodbye to Drake.