After receiving a warning from the Angel of Death that Leo is on his list of souls to collect, Piper casts a spell to make everybody look like Leo so Death can't complete his job. She then turns to the Elders and Avatars for help in keeping Leo safe, only to discover that it's Leo's destiny to die. As a result, Piper turns to the Angel of Destiny in an attempt to cut a deal to keep him alive. As Billie tracks down a lead in her attempt to locate her sister, Paige has her first date with Henry.

Thanks to Billie's obsession to find the demons who took her sister, demons she has previously tortured help a former parolee of Henry's take a bank full of customers' hostage. As a result, Paige has to use her Whitelighter powers to save Henry after he gets injured. Meanwhile, thanks to Leo's absence, Wyatt begins to act up, causing Piper to get to her wit's end.