When a "cool" new couple moves in across the street, Reagan and Chris become obsessed with finding out every detail about them. Elsewhere, Ava struggles with the fact that baby Amy does not like her, especially when she takes a liking to Calvin.

Reagan's love for online shopping takes a bizarre turn when she and Chris go on the hunt for a practical family car. Concerned about their newborn's welfare, Chris aims to negotiate a deal for the perfect new car that is safe but not boring. Meanwhile, Ava decides to take on more serious talk show topics, but is overwhelmed by the amount of preparation it takes to pull it off.