Jeff is shocked, his mother worried, when his popular coach and scholastic father figure is found fatally shot at school. Shane Wyatt, the eternally pestered boy, was seen with a handgun to scare his bullies. Jim sympathizes but has to make him admit having shot the coach, albeit accidentally in a struggle over the gun.

A body is found at a popular beachside bar with a large diamond ring in his pocket. Longworth sifts through the sands of the various characters at the bar, revealing a complicated love triange that may have ended in murder. Meanwhile, Callie has some news for Longworth that will change everything.