Phoebe becomes heartbroken when she thinks her tickets to the MKTO concert were destroyed in the shredder, but she does not know the tickets are with Max, who has secret plans to take his crush to the concert to make her fall for him. Meanwhile, Nora feels her family is replacing her with new paper shredder machine that Hank buys.

Phoebe and Cherry's friendship is tested when only one of them makes the cheerleader squad. Meanwhile, Billy and Nora want to keep a stray cat as their own pet.