Jeff is cajoled into giving up hockey tickets so he can go with Audrey to her boss's party, where he spends the night trying to avoid hearing the score of the game; and, at the game, Russell is embarrassed when Timmy roots for the visiting team.

Audrey and Jeff travel to Nebraska so Audrey can attend her 20th high-school reunion and tell everyone about her successful life in New York. Meanwhile, Russell inadvertently wreaks havoc at Timmy's dinner party.