Mrs. Dabney pays Teddy to watch her beloved cat, Kaboodle, while she goes out of town. Meanwhile, in an effort to find things in common with his crush, Gabe tells her that his parents are divorced and he's an only child living with his mom.

Teddy gets PJ and Gabe to help her throw Amy and Bob a surprise dinner for their anniversary. But when Charlie loses her favorite blankie, Teddy tries to track it down from the donation truck and PJ gets locked out of the house with Charlie inside.