Elmer's transition out of the Amish leads to an unsavory addiction; Laurie struggles with the pressure of converting to Orthodox Judaism; Ashley sets out to ease the tension between her conservative Catholic family and her Muslim husband.

Lindsey takes drastic measures to stop Elmer's porn habit. Eli's mom questions Laurie's dedication to Orthodox Judaism. Ashley's plan to bring Mohammed and her family together backfires. Tensions rise when Kris's dad pushes salvation onto Lensa.