As the anniversary of Devalos's daughter's death comes to pass, Devalos is haunted by memories of the traumatic event. Meanwhile, Allison has dreams of the extreme measures Devalos went to in order to put his daughter's killer in jail, and how Devalos' past actions may have future consequences.

Allison keeps seeing the face of one man in the faces of other people, including Joe, and must figure out why. Meanwhile, Ariel has a difficult time babysitting a mischievous boy.