Alumni reunite in Dillon for homecoming, including a former state champ with dark secrets; Billy Riggins and Tyra plan the ultimate after-game party; Smash feels pressure to impress a college recruiter; and Jason becomes more suspicious of Lyla and Tim.

Lyla and Tim are alienated as rumors about their relationship spread; Smash puts his health at risk in his attempt to improve his performance on the field; Julie and Matt go on their first date; and the Panthers face the intimidating Gatling High team.