While completing his community service, Rusty discovers a symbol for a secret Amphora Society that is actively recruiting members. Knowing that Cappie was on a search to find the hidden lair during his freshman year, Rusty gets Dale to help him solve the mystery to get back in Cappie's good graces. Will Cappie be impressed?

Overwhelmed with loneliness since Max left for his internship, Casey finds herself latching onto her ZBZ sister's social activities and ultimately interfering with Rusty's new blossoming romance with Jordan. To what lengths will Rusty go to put a stop to Casey's craziness?