The students at CRU feel the ramifications of the Kappa Tau's "End of the World" Party. Rusty risks being dropped from the honors program if he cannot raise his grade in organic chemistry and Casey adjusts to single life.

As Rusty and Jordan are awkwardly deciding when to take their relationship to the next level, the Gotcha Game comes between them as the final two players left in the game. Cappie becomes Rusty's bodyguard and Rebecca becomes Jordan's, as the happy couple battle it out so their house can win the game. Who will pull the trigger first?