Casey and Cappie find themselves facing a harsh reality after spontaneously spending the night together at the ZBZ house. Adding to Casey's personal sense of responsibility, Katherine confides in Casey about her own new romance and asks Casey's advice.

Kappa Tau faces academic probation when one of their pledges mysteriously receives straight F‘s, the KT‘s suspect Omega Chi and Dale are behind it. Rebecca uses the investigation as her post Evan break up coping mechanism and discovers that Omega Chi is actually playing a trick on Dale. Evan takes revenge on Casey for his break up with Rebecca by attempting to make her look less than capable in her Law school studies.