After a "Messin' With Lewbert" sketch, Sam finds out that Lewbert had a relatively normal life at one time that included no wart, a modeling career, and a girlfriend. This convinces the iCarly crew that reuniting Lewbert with his ex-girlfriend will make him happy, and stop him from hassling everyone at Bushwell Apartments. Boy, are they mistaken!

After Carly & Sam agreed to help Fleck and Dave make a video, Carly and Sam must choose sides when the comedians begin to fight. Fleck keeps infuriating Dave's restrictive father much to Dave's dismay, and the girls are drawn into the conflict.