When a a recently engaged woman disappears from her engagement party, the team discovers her background is riddled with frauds and scams. Meanwhile, Sam reluctantly sees a therapist to help her process recent events at work.

When Doris Lovett, a mother from a small town, is abducted in the middle of the day from outside her home, Jack realizes that the case bears an uncomfortable similarity to a serial killer case he dealt with 12 years ago.