Father Bob from Saints Peter and Paul Church in Hoboken comes to Buddy, looking to him to make a special cake that looks like stained glass for a parishioner in his church. With Danny's 50th birthday coming around the corner, Buddy and his family decide to make him a special cake and throw him a special cake to celebrate. Tired of the way Mary mistreats the bakery employees, Buddy has to let her go.

Buddy and his staff are asked to make a special cake to commemorate the 125th anniversary of the Statue of Liberty. While they are working on the cake, everyone starts to congratulate Mauro on gaining his American citizenship. Buddy then creates a basketball themed cake for Bob Hurley, a beloved high school basketball coach, who has been at the helm of St. Anthony High School's basketball team for the past 40 years. Meanwhile, Mary gives the family a piece of her mind at dinner that causes her to get into hot water.