Samira uses the disappearance of a neighbor's dog as a ruse to convince her new friends to break into the Victorian so she can confirm her suspicions about Gary; once inside, the group is shocked to find far more than they were looking for.

As glimpses of Rob and Naveen's past surface, Samira pieces together key clues and makes a startling realization about their strange neighbor across the street-one that unexpectedly turns everyone's worlds upside down.