After Van is selected player of the week on his football team, he talks Reba into hosting and preparing the traditional pre-game dinner before the upcoming football game. When Cheyenne accidentally serves the wrong potato salad to the team, Van and they guys are certain they're going to lose. Fearing that Cheyenne will face ridicule, Reba finds a way to save the day.

Kyra does not want to spend time with her father since it includes Barbara Jean; Cheyenne and Van plan to move out.