After telling Van and Cheyenne about all the Christmas traditions that were started after Cheyenne was born, Reba is thrown for a loop when they decide to spend Elizabeth's first Christmas creating their own traditions and not spending it with Reba and the rest of the family. Her day goes from bad to worse when Kyra and Jake tell her that they also don't want to spend Christmas with her. So, she takes the huge feast she made down to the homeless shelter and gets a reminder from a special visitor at the shelter. Upon arriving back at home, Reba's foul mood improves when her loved ones plans backfire and return home to celebrate the holiday with her.

After Cheyenne and Van have a pregnancy scare, Reba lays down some house rules about not bringing another baby into the world while they're still living with her. As a result, they decide to move out. Meanwhile, following the baby scare, Barbara Jean tells Brock that her biological is ticking and would like to have another baby. When Brock tells her that he had a vasectomy after getting her pregnant, the couple has a huge fight and Barbara Jean turns to Reba for advice on what to do.