When Kyra gets mad at Reba for not agreeing with Brock and Barbara Jean about getting a cell phone, and as a result starts hanging out more with her stepmom. Meanwhile, after Brock suggests that an overwhelmed Barbara Jean get a makeover, everyone is stunned at how she looks. Van decides to go on a diet and gets confused when Cheyenne overreacts when he suggests she diet as well.

It's Valentine's Day and when Brian asks Reba out for a date, she panics and pretends to be sick, only to have her plan backfire. Meanwhile, Jake is facing dilemma when he has a crush in his class and is reluctant to give her a special card. When Van goes to Brock for advice on what to give Cheyenne for Valentine's Day, the guys end up getting in a competition over who gives their respective wife a more romantic evening.