After Cheyenne and Van have a pregnancy scare, Reba lays down some house rules about not bringing another baby into the world while they're still living with her. As a result, they decide to move out. Meanwhile, following the baby scare, Barbara Jean tells Brock that her biological is ticking and would like to have another baby. When Brock tells her that he had a vasectomy after getting her pregnant, the couple has a huge fight and Barbara Jean turns to Reba for advice on what to do.

When Kyra gets mad at Reba for not agreeing with Brock and Barbara Jean about getting a cell phone, and as a result starts hanging out more with her stepmom. Meanwhile, after Brock suggests that an overwhelmed Barbara Jean get a makeover, everyone is stunned at how she looks. Van decides to go on a diet and gets confused when Cheyenne overreacts when he suggests she diet as well.