When a pro baseball player is accused of rape, the team investigates his alibi, leading to an unexpected revelation. Meanwhile, Jordan's growing jealousy of Woody and Lu's relationship reaches new heights; and Nigel is determined to find the family of a fighter pilot whose frozen body was discovered.

While trying to return some personal items to a deceased man's family, Macy is beaten and taken hostage by the deranged homeowner, who is also holding a boy captive. Meanwhile, Jordan refuses to believe that a kindly old janitor could be a suspect in a jewelry scam.