After Patricia rescues Rufus from the hospital, he disappears. Amber attempts to help Alfie remember what happened in the cellar by hypnotizing him. Nina & Fabian solve the next part of the mystery but have their reward confiscated when Victor catches them.

Mick finds out about the pictures and fears he may be expelled. As the play begins, Nina slips out to retrieve the puzzle piece from Victor's safe. Mick and Mara kiss onstage and realize they have feelings for each other. Patricia receives a message from Joy. Nina makes a surprising discovery in Victor's desk but becomes trapped when Victor returns unexpectedly.