Jerome poses as Alfie's savior after his failed cellar mission by reopening the sarcophagus. He demands that Alfie repay him by secretly passing him information on Sibuna. Nina works out that the next puzzle is inside the chandelier. Amber distracts Victor by pretending to faint so that Nina can get the relic. Mara and Mick finally kiss and make up. Alfie and Jerome fall out when Jerome accidentally reveals that he is working for Rufus. Fabian and Nina near the end of their search but still have one more place to look for the last puzzle piece, which is in the stuffed black crow in Victor's office. Written on the last puzzle piece is "END." Nina begins to hear voices and when she tells Fabian about it, he questions if she's truly the Chosen One, and not Joy. This scares Nina and she gets defensive about it.

Jerome gives Rufus Alfie's puzzle piece, much to the dismay of Alfie. Meanwhile Fabian works out that the puzzle pieces may actually be the seven pieces of the Cup of Ankh. Sibuna goes to put the Cup together when Alfie admits to letting Jerome give the piece to Rufus. Jerome is scared of Rufus and agrees to get the piece back by trying to lock Rufus in the cellar. The plan backfires when Jerome has to go down with Rufus, instead of Rufus going down by himself. They call Victor like they had planned and he goes down to be surprised by Rufus who has drunk the elixir. Jerome manages to escape while they talk, but just as Nina is about to close the passageway, Rufus grabs her arm to stop her.