Mick and Mara make up. Mick leaves the house. Fabian rescues Nina and Amber, and then Nina, Amber, and Fabian rescue Patricia with the help of Mrs. Andrews. Rufus escapes and is confirmed to be an antagonist. Nina, Amber, Fabian, and Patricia video chat with Joy when Victor says he'll give them "answers".

The contest for School Representative heats up, with Mara running. Jerome asks Mara out, but gets rejected when he starts insulting Mick. The latest riddle leads Sibuna to the grandfather clock, but when they open it, it is found to be empty, making it seem like someone has already taken the puzzle piece. Alfie is still fishing around so the gang tells him he was right all along about aliens. Then, during a Sibuna meeting, Nina opens the 5th puzzle piece and a secret message appears on the wall of the house itself.