Patricia feels that Piper is cramping her style. Eddie feels bad that he had kissed Piper accidentally, but Piper tells him it's best not to tell Patricia. Jerome learns from Jasper that Trudy has been kidnapped by the Collector and he will need to find a Frobisher Smythe artifact to buy her back. Victor decides to invite Gustave for dinner and Alfie decides to volunteer for the entertainment by doing magic.

The Sibunas are delighted when Alfie reveals Victor's amulet in one piece - all part of the trick. Then Nina realizes that someone had moved the dollhouse and decides to hide it. Piper says goodbye and gives Patricia her necklace. Eddie comes and sees Piper's necklace on Patricia and believes that she's Piper and tells "Piper" that he feels bad that he still didn't tell Patricia about their kiss. Jerome believes Vera has stolen the dollhouse and Nina and Fabian realize that Vera is after the mask. Joy pairs Eddie up with Mara to do a story on the revamped school website. Victor and Vera realize Alfie has tricked them and that he has the real amulet.