The Collector rejects Jasper's offering of Sarah's doll and Vera doesn't see Jerome. But then Vera realizes that Victor needs its glass eye - it could be the next reflector! The Sibunas find out that there's a reflector in a mosaic that Trudy has thrown out. Fabian learns from Joy that it's in the library and the Sibunas recover it. Amber forgets to lock up the dollhouse and Jerome gets his hands on it. The only thing is that he doesn't know that Eddie and Mara's camera had recorded the whole thing. The Sibunas find their third reflector in the library, but Fabian now knows Jasper has been lying to him.

After Jasper rips off the Collector's hood, Jerome learns that Rufus is back! The Sibunas learn that Eddie had backup files on a USB drive, even though they tried to infect the picture files on his computer, so Nina dispatches her friends on different missions; Fabian has to try and convince Joy not to run the story, Patricia must apologize to Eddie, and Amber and Alfie must steal Eddie's camera. Jerome and Jasper follow Rufus and Jerome tells Jasper who he is, and they fall back. Vera finds another reflector; a piece of stained-glass from the window in her room.