The adults are on the Sibunas' tail, looking for their second sinner. Patricia plans to tell Eddie how she really feels about him, little knowing that Victor and Denby have trapped him in the crypt.

The Sibunas puzzle over a riddle which leads them to a secret room. Mara is disappointed to learn she has inherited a dog. Denby drives a wedge between Eddie and Patricia in her quest for Frobisher's next sinner.