As her crush on Josh intensifies, Sabrina is torn between helping him study for an exam and watching Harvey's football game. Desperate, she enlists Dreama's help, while Hilda and Zilda's search for a housekeeper leads to a surprise reunion.

Sabrina is finding it difficult to deal with Harvey's romance with Colette, and despite Dreama's best efforts, they seem unlikely to reconcile. Meanwhile, Hilda and Zelda decide to make Thanksgiving dinner, and zap in two pilgrims to help.