Sabrina gets approved for an Other Realm credit card and as a result, goes overboard buying things and becomes spoiled rotten. When Hilda and Zelda see how much stuff she bought, they order her to donate everything to a rummage sale to benefit the orphans in Honduras. However, Sabrina gives away her aunts' unwanted magical items instead, and as a result, her friends buy and fall victim to the items' magical powers. Meanwhile, Salem wants to get a pet of his own.

As her crush on Josh intensifies, Sabrina is torn between helping him study for an exam and watching Harvey's football game. Desperate, she enlists Dreama's help, while Hilda and Zilda's search for a housekeeper leads to a surprise reunion.