In this episode of Fact or Faked: Paranormal Files, Bill, Lanisha and Devin pay a visit to a local watering hole in Humble, Texas where surveillance video of an exploding ashtray purports to validate the bar's long-rumored history of poltergeist activity. After attempting to explain the video with scientific experiments, they embark on a night investigation with hair-raising results. Meanwhile, Ben, Jael and Austin get their passports stamped in Calacoaya, Mexico where they investigate a chilling piece of footage of an alleged flying witch, known in popular Latin lore as La Bruja Lechuza. After a series of inventive experiments attempting to replicate the video in question, the team hits a home run.

Ben, Austin and Jael investigate a mysterious hovering light over the waters of Bodega Bay, California. Bill, Lanisha and Devin travel to the Jersey Shore's Paramount Theater where amateur ghost hunters caught a humanoid apparition.