Romance finds its way back into Marin's life in the way of gifts from Jack, as well as her publisher, Stuart Maxson, who'd like to pick up where they left off. She also juggles being both maid of honor and best man for Patrick and Annie while trying to make their dreams come true for their bachelor and bachelorette parties. Meanwhile, Sara struggles with minister Eric's church policy of no sex outside of marriage, and Ben, feeling off his game since his heart scare, considers purchasing a professional hockey team.

Marin has second thoughts about her feelings for Jack and invites him to be her wedding date. Patrick and Annie's wedding is threatened by dangerous and unforeseen events. Meanwhile, Jane flies in for their nuptials and has an impulsive reaction when she sees Sam with his date; Mary Alice develops a relationship with a very unlikely Elmoian; Dick and Celia become way too attached; Sara helps Eric deal with the fallout of his actions toward his congregation; and Cash returns to Elmo.