For the first time ever, Nev and Max receive emails from opposite sides of the same online romance, each concerned that the other may be a catfish! The guys are taken aback when one side decides to follow through with their marriage plans!

Colleen met Tony online and fell madly in love. Though they've never met, Tony proposed to Colleen over the phone and she accepted! Now, Nev and Max help her finally face the truth to reveal the mystery man she's engaged to!