Moving on from a toxic breakup, Alfred's thirsty to find Adonis, the elusive man of his dreams; but as they dig for answers, word that Nev and Kamie are in town leads to the most explosive confrontation in the Catfish history.

Nev and Kamie receive an anonymous email from a whistleblower reporting a catfishing! But when our hosts arrive to help the named victim, they uncover a deeper conspiracy of deception that only the secret informant can solve.