Paul met Caitea on Xbox and fell madly in love, but one day Caitea just disappeared! A decade later, Nev and Kamie help Paul find his first love. But what they find is one of the most shocking reveals in Catfish history!

Courtney has been mad in love with her Turkish boyfriend for 3 years, but she met Chris roleplaying and is wondering if he's just a fantasy? Nev and Kamie cross digital borders to hunt the identity of her international mystery man!