Gabby is heartbroken when she discovers her online love, Kendrick, was killed; when Gabby's cousin suspects she's been mourning a fictional character, she calls in Nev and Kamie to uncover a truth that's stranger than fiction.

Hayley met Britani on Instagram and fell fast in love, but Hayley's sister thinks Britani is suspect; now, with Hayley planning a dangerous trip to meet Britani, her sister is worried and calls Nev and Kamie to find answers soon.