After finding an abandoned baby in his lifeguard tower, Logan mistakenly believes it's his that one of his many former girlfriends left for him to raise. Mitch and Hobie have their hands full, volunteering to watch the infant temporarily. Logan briefly discovers the joy of fatherhood, much to everyone's surprise at Baywatch, until a newscast describes the baby's kidnapping from a hospital. Meanwhile, Stephanie prepares Cody for the Olympic swimming trials in the 100-meter freestyle; he wins.

After an alligator living in a storm drain attacks swimmers, Mitch, Logan, and Cody hunt for the creature. C.J., Caroline, and Neely compete to become the cover model for the swimsuit issue of Inside Sports Magazine.