On this episode of Haunted Collector, John Zaffis and his team head to Warwick, New York to visit newlyweds Frank and Valentina Muto. Since moving into the floor above their Italian villa restaurant, this couple's idyllic life has been disrupted by strange, disembodied voices, guests who are inexplicably overcome with fear, and harrowing screams in the middle of the night. The team then travels to Stephenson, Virginia to investigate unexplained phenomena at Historic Jordan Springs, an event hall owned by Tonie Wallace. Tonie and her staff have spotted ghostly faces in the windows, seen doors slam shut on their own, and witnessed a cloaked shadow figure that seems to lurk throughout the grounds.

On this episode of Haunted Collector, John Zaffis and his team visit Tim Brazeal, a preservationist who is restoring an abandoned church rectory in Sedamsville, Ohio. Tim and his coworkers' efforts to repair the historic property have been upended by what they call unexplained and threatening paranormal activity. The team then travels to Windber, Pennsylvania to investigate strange phenomena at the former Grand Midway Hotel. Now a residence for Blair Murphy, his girlfriend and other roommates, witnesses attest to persistent whispers, shadows, and poltergeist activity.