Amy hears the case of a teenager protesting against discrimination by his school. Her friend's husband tries to kiss her after giving her a pair of shoes and she has to decide whether to be honest about this.

Amy hears the case of a pregnant woman living in a group of people who believe that medical treatment is against the will of God. After a terrible shock, Peter gets a DUI and Gillian tells Maxine and Amy that she thinks he is an alcoholic.