Casefile: Lake "Eerie" - Henry Baker is driving home with his family when his wife spots strange lights hovering over Lake Erie. Casefile: Phasers on Stun - On a remote ranch in Argentina strange lights turn violent when three women try to investigate them.

Casefile: Catnip - In Ohio, two officers see a bizarre bright light flying in the night sky, Police dispatch advises them to follow the object, triggering a huge car chase. Casefile: Swampcraft - An ex-Military outdoorsmen tries to communicate with a UFO in the Florida Everglades.