Cassie receives an unexpected visit from her college roommate Autumn Delaney, who harbors resentment toward Cassie over a past event. Cassie relies on her magical instincts to help Autumn through her unresolved feelings before she sabotages Middleton's celebrations.

Cassie helps Joy mark her mother's birthday by planting a tree and discovers a time capsule that Grace buried years ago; Sam competes against Middleton favorites in a chili cook-off.