Isla's father tries to innocence card but Isla knows better, yet she can't help but hope for a scenario where she isn't a murderer's daughter. Isla and Tina investigate for themselves and learn there might be something to his alibi.

Isla tries to track down Jonah Jacob, the son of a victim who was a client of Isla's mom. Nathan arrives in town looking for Isla, but first pays a visit to Isla's father who is racked with guilt after learning how Isla betrayed her legal guardian to make her escape.