To honor a bet that he lost to Mark, former New York Yankee Alex Rodriguez works a shift at the Fenway Wahlburgers restaurant and Paul is shocked by the reception A-Rod gets from the Boston Red Sox fans. Mark and Donnie confront Paul about his hostility towards social media, and plot to exponentially increase his Instagram followers, and give him a ‘signature tagline' worthy of a celebrity chef. Phyllis and Alma take an oil painting class, and the male model gives them a lot more to work with than they expected.

Donnie breaks ground on his St. Charles, Ill., location; Alma, Johnny Drama and Phyllis plan a '50s-themed carhop behind Paul's back; Brandon gets into the dog food market with the help of Paul and Alma's dogs.