Leo performs a magic act to earn a spot in the school talent show but loses his slot to Chase who uses his powers to cheat and create "magic" of his own. Leo then sets out to sabotage Chase but inadvertently releases Chase's rampaging alter ego, "Spike," to wreak havoc on the school. Meanwhile a frustrated Bree watches as Adam and Owen attempt to use butter as art.

The Lab Rats inadvertently ruin Davenport's million dollar painting and use their powers to cover their mistake. Things go from bad to worse when Davenport attempts to sell the painting and is accused of attempting to sell forged art.