The cast reacts to never-before-seen footage of Colt asking Elise out on a date. Cortney and Elise discuss the mysterious noises that came from Rob's pool at the resort. Rob watches Jen be intimate with Cole and criticizes their bedroom behavior.

The cast watches never-before-seen footage from the morning of Colt's injury, and Colt is shocked at Rob's lack of support. Chantel reveals a secret kiss that she had with Jen at girls' night. Rob calls Cole out for his overbearing behavior.