The sequel to Janette Oke's best-selling novel and the Hallmark Channel Original Movie, Love Comes Softly, picks up with Missie now in her 20's, and an elementary school teacher in her small town, finding herself torn between two worlds and the love of two very different men.

Willie LaHaye and his wife Missie must cope with the tragic death of their infant daughter while struggling to keep their frontier ranch going. Meanwhile, Willie, the new sheriff, finds himself being used by Sam Doros, the mayor and richest man in town, in a scheme to foreclose on other ranchers' properties. Further complicating matters is the budding romance between Missie and Willie's adopted teenage son and Doros' pampered daughter.