John's former college roommate at Harvard visits to seek forgiveness for past offenses, but John refuses to pardon his old friend. Meanwhile, at the diner, Bob becomes convinced that he is going to die soon; and at the office Linda accuses Margaret of having an affair.

John gets upset when a patient refuses to take any more medication because he believes God is healing him through prayer. At the diner, Bob brags that he is part Native American and tries to cash in on his newfound heritage, and Linda attempts to keep up the charade in her "long-distance" relationship with a fellow New Yorker.