A criminal is stalking elderly people, emptying their bank accounts and murdering them. In other events, the mayor comes clean about his past and Ella isn't sure whether to accept a date offer.

Two groups of Santas fight over the best corners for charity. In the meantime, Mannion is threatened by an anonymous phone caller claiming to have been mistreated in the past, a truck of Christmas merchandise is stolen and a high-ranking senator is arrested for drinking and driving.