Bill and Judy try to find new friends to do things with as couples, but they think they won't find an equally fun pair until they meet the parents of one of Lauren's friends. They seem to be a perfect match, but they only want to spend time with Judy. Meanwhile, Brian and Linda buy matching cell phones, and he sees something disturbing when he picks hers up by mistake.

Expensive concert tickets are at the center of a game of "one-upmanship" between Bill and Judy as they try to prove who is better at finding things. Marion cautions them to work together as a team, but the advice comes too late and Marion offers a surprising solution to the situation.